And as it often does, my shallowness paid off for me here. Sturgeon’s book was a surprise in the best possible way. I sat down to read it and realized immediately that I was staring at a small selection of serious talent. Sturgeon’s Trees is much more than a debut. It is a revelation, an entirely new thing, and at the same time feels a bit like coming home. That’s because Sturgeon’s voice is part prophet, part fierce cynic–a synthesis of Blake and Eliot, with a bit of Stevens in there as well. These poems are difficult, nourishing examinations of perception, of memory, of culture, of love, of connection and loss and disillusionment. Of the dull/sharp duality of modern society, and a fondness for the old ways lost. Sturgeon cleverly lays in allusions to his poetical predecessors, with nods populating the poems like, “come into the garden-city, love/away, come away.”
These poems read like beautiful new music built over the old, with stanzas like this one in “Gourmand”:
People saw me a starving criminal
and mildly kicked me, or flicked me crumbs,
while I etched a new map of the world
inside my roving mouth.
And Sturgeon’s gift with words, with repetition and form and sound and playful lightness contrasted with solemn weight, is apparent throughout the collection as well. Another example, from “La Ballade du phasme:”
Black Moon snuck behind an Oriental screen.
Poor Miss Black Moon jitterbugs and unseen
spies occasion to whistle and unwind,
when her invitation is maligned.
When she falls, black moon sinks along the shine,says What the world is this. Isn’t mine.
The poems are at their most lovely, most deadly, most achingly sad when Sturgeon’s ghosts of the past hang side by side with the wrecked modern world. My favorite poem in the collection, “Epistola Cantabrigiensis” seemed to me a more compact, softer echo of Ginsberg’s Howl or Eliot’s The Waste Land. A sigh for modern life instead of a scream, it pins the heart to the wall just the same with lines like, “Going between two places, I never want to arrive, and would rather go on, perpetually a passenger,” and later “I don’t care that life will end in an explosion of guilt and cancer./Criticism is rarely not for clowns.”
Much like the trees on the cover of his debut collection, Sturgeon’s poems here are jagged, jarring, yet strikingly beautiful with a melody, and order all their own. We recognize them, we recognize what they mourn, we recognize in them what we, too, have lost and what and who has gone this way before. And yet in that recognition, something stubborns shouts and sings of a new thing, a new way of speaking about it, and a path that hasn’t been tried as we try to find our way out of this thicket of memory and cultural detritus. I’d highly recommend picking up a copy of Trees and traveling that twisted path yourself.